Why moderated comments can be a problem

You might know already that I don’t like moderating comments; I did for a long time because of spam, but nowadays I prefer filtering comments out with mod_security based on User-Agent and other diagnostics. One of the reasons why I don’t like moderated comments is that, often times, comments can correct a wrong blog post and make it not extremely bad.

I don’t pretend I’m extremely good at what I do and that I never make mistakes; I’m sure I do, but if I say something very stupid, usually somebody corrects me on the comments, and the post still keep a value. When I see posts about people reinventing the wheel, and making it hexagonal for some reason (like reinventing grep --include -r with a script using find and a for loop), and find out that the comments are moderated, then I’m usually appalled. First, because lots of users that don’t know better will read the post and apply what it says without thinking twice about it. Second, because in the comments, that appeared in a batch right away, beside a number of duplicate suggestions, there has been even more suggestions in a number of polygons, but just a couple of really round wheels. You probably know what I’m referring to if you follow some of the planets out there, I don’t really want to name names here.

Today, another example of moderated comments that hinder clearing up a blog post that isn’t really proper. When you rant about a software or a feature, especially when you explicitly say you don’t understand why it does what it does, leaving open comments allows for people to actually solve the mystery for you; if you moderate it, you’re probably wasting time of more than one person who has the answer, since they’ll probably try to explain it when they see no comments present already.

Sigh.

2 thoughts on “Why moderated comments can be a problem

  1. I have a similar gripe with this site/project:http://www.commandlinefu.com/Besides the more low-level gripes of useless uses of cat, there are a lot of “recipes” that are not only convoluted but very often not robust, much less portable. Thing is: you can only comment on a recipe if you have registered, which frankly can’t be bothered to do.

    Like

  2. Regarding that particular `grep -r` situation: I think it’s awful that grep even has such a switch.find is the tool for dealing w/ non-trivial sets of files. if you’re invoking a command on such a set, stuff it into find’s -exec (you wouldn’t believe how few people even know it exists; it’s a shame). if anything is reinventing the wheel, grep’s -r and -include/-include-dir/… are. if anything, find’s options should be improved upon, the grep folks appear to be completely incapable of writing something that’s supposed be nothing more than a cli for a regex library already.and yes, find (dir) (criteria) -exec (cmd) (; or +) is a bit more to type but there’s aliases and functions for that in shell!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s